The Stupidity of Computers
I read this essay and got a lot from this inspired quote:
Lanier asks us to consider, for example, the humble file, or rather, to consider a world without “files.” (The first iteration of the Macintosh, which never shipped, didn’t have files.) I confess this thought experiment stumped me about as much as if I’d been asked to consider persisting in a world without “time.” And then consider further that these designs, so often taken up in a slap-dash, last-minute fashion, become “locked in,” and, because they are software, used by millions, too often become impossible to adapt, or change. MIDI, an inflexible, early-1980s digital music protocol for connecting different musical components, such as a keyboard and a computer, takes no account of, say, the fluid line of a soprano’s coloratura; it is still the basis of most of the tinny music we hear every day—in our phones, in the charts, in elevators—simply because it became, in software terms, too big to fail, too big to change.
Lanier wants us to be attentive to the software into which we are “locked in.” Is it really fulfilling our needs? Or are we reducing the needs we feel in order to convince ourselves that the software isn’t limited?
I think all of these are points worth considering. Google is developing an augmented reality platform with Project Glass, and one wonders how this is in fact "augmenting" our reality. Rather, it seems like Google Glass is essentially giving us a constant connection to the Internet and allowing us to overlay some of the structure of the Internet onto the everyday world. It's almost like saying that the ontology of the Internet (and specifically Google products) is an improvement over to the messy, rather open-ended ontology of the everyday world.
On the other hand, the Internet has been a wonderful thing in a lot of ways, and I honestly couldn't say say the world would be a better without Google. Academic research, learning, and communication have been greatly improved with their search. Even platforms like Facebook and Twitter were integral in organizing protests during the Arab Spring and organizing relief efforts in Haiti during the Earthquake. I mean, even Reddit is a useful service, sometimes. You can learn a lot from strangers when they're not being terrible and stupid.
I don't think it's as hopeless as the article makes it seem. We've always had to live with imposed ontologies, whether they were from Aristotle or from religious upbringing or etc. Internet ontologies seem more fluid and easier to change than the former (even the dreaded MIDI used as an example in the above quote is pretty non-existent at this point). Also, the development of stupid ontologies means those that are smarter and understand the limitations of the ontology can learn to subvert and overthrow it. Also, given that computers are "dumber" than people in a lot of ways, it may be easier to fight back and change a terrible system that is based on computer structures than in previous generations where ontologies were imposed upon us through the less predictable but oh-so-human political/social/economic structures.