His Master's Voice

Share
His Master's Voice by Barraud

I finished His Master's Voice by Stanisław Lem today. It's a science fiction novel that deals with the discovery of a neutrino message from outer space and the group of scientists that try to decode it. I'm not ruining anything by saying that the majority of the book is the researchers tossing up hundreds of hypotheses of what the letter could be, but never proving that any of those hypotheses are correct. The narrator, a stolid and cynical mathematician named Peter Hogarth, makes it clear at the beginning of the book that the project, in the end, failed to accomplish its goal. From the first chapter, he states:

The amount of space devoted to the achievements with occasional footnote mentions of what remained unknown-those very proportions suggested that we had mastered the Labyrinth, with the exception of a few corridors-dead ends, no doubt, probably buried in rubble-- whereas in fact we did not get as far as the entrance. Doomed forever to conjecture, having chipped a few flecks from the lock of that sealed gate, we delighted in the glitter that gilded our fingertips. But of what was locked we know nothing.

The book is much more a story full of interesting ideas than a story with a driving plot. I think it can be best summarized as a philosophical musing of the picture that shares its name. The dog recognizes something familiar in the sound from the gramophone. But what is the voice saying? Is the message directed towards the dog, or does it have nothing to do with it? Is that recording singing a song, or is it explaining a complicated mathematical proof, or instructions on where the dog can find a storage of treats? Could it be reciting a chapter from Dickens, or just reading a grocery list out loud? And the dog in turn, how could it ever conceive of what it's even listening to? The sound is a familiar voice, but how is the voice being produced? There is a lot of physics and technology behind how a gramophone works that many humans don't understand, much less a dog.

The best part about the picture, though, is the dog's curiosity. That look of puzzlement, the attempt to figure out what is going on, and under that, the inevitable failure. That's also the most interesting part of the book. The narrator presents the story through a worldview that, from what I've experienced, is standard to most mathematicians and physicists. The creation of the Earth and life on Earth was a statistical incident, controlled by the neutral laws of physics. Humanity is also a product of the similarly random process of evolution. Therefore, everything concerning humans and the universe they live in is both completely arbitrary, yet necessary. Humans occupy no special place in the universe, so their chance to decode the message has nothing to do with whether they want it badly enough, or whether they work hard enough, but only on where these random processes have placed them. The narrator himself has a rather dark sense of humor, and states it in another way, aware of the negative spin that the following description places on humanity:

Humanity is a hunchback who, in ignorance of the fact that it is possible not to be hunchbacked, for thousands of years has sought an indication of a Higher Necessity in his hump, because he will accept any theory but the one that says that his deformity is purely accidental, that no one bestowed it upon him as part of a master plan, that it serves absolutely no purpose, for the thing was determined by the twists and turns of anthropogenesis.

Quite gloomy, though the narrator himself usually maintains a coldly neutral approach when discussing the human condition. For him, there is no good or evil in reality, only what happens. This leads to an interesting approach to the problem of evil, and how it applies to politics and humanity. The story itself has mainly pessimistic overtones, though. There is even a point where the scientists decode a small portion of the stellar message, and with the tiny knowledge gained, stumble upon the potential means to create a life-obliterating weapon. His Master's Voice was also written during the Cold War, so there quite a few comments on the political climate of the time, and the propensity of countries to launch themselves towards destruction at the quickest instant given the smallest opportunity.

Still, the book is immensely thought-provoking. I know I got a lot out of its comments on what it means to be a scientist and to do scientific work. A memorable remark was on what changes when a scientist begins working directly under the direction of a political body. Namely, that government scientists can easily become the equivalent of a truffle-hunting pigs, highly useful and effective, but not exactly respected.

His Master's Voice is neither a feel-good story of wonder and connectedness like Sagan's Contact, nor a Lovecraftian caveat of the terrible insanity that results from learning forbidden knowledge. HMV is the story of humanity staring into the abyss that is the universe, and being utterly unable to comprehend the returning gaze.