Brave New World Revisited

Share

I found an interesting article about Brave New World, written for its 75 anniversary. Everyone has a different opinion of what kind of world large scientific progress will bring us. To some it's a Utopia of cures for most illnesses, super long lifespans, solutions to nature's confounding questions, and general well being for all. For others it's a dystopic future where the main human values become efficiency and consumption, the habits and workings of the brain are manipulated and exploited, and freedom is replaced by a stagnant order. The following is a quote from Bertrand Russell's review of Brave New World:

But we are shocked—more, I think, than we ought to be—by the idea of molding people scientifically instead of allowing them to grow. We have a notion that we can choose what we will be, and that we should not wish to be robbed of this choice by scientific manipulators drugging us before we are born, giving us electric shocks in infancy, and whispering platitudes to us throughout our childhood.
But this feeling is, of course, irrational. In the course of nature the embryo grows through natural causes. The infant learns haphazard lessons of pleasure and pain which determine his taste. The child listens to moral propaganda, which may fail through being unscientific, but which, none the less, is intended to mold the character just as much as Mr. Huxley’s whispering machines. It seems, therefore, that we do not object to molding a human being, provided it is done badly; we only object when it is done well.
What we cling to so desperately is the illusion of freedom, an illusion which is tacitly negated by all moral instruction and all propaganda. To us human life would be intolerable without this illusion. In Mr. Huxley’s Brave New World men live quite comfortably without it.

While the main article that this quote is couched in seems to imply that being completely scientific means having to give up freedom, creativity, and morality, I don't think that scientific progress will necessarily lead an abolishment all these kinds of values. I'm still of the view that since science and technology don't refer to values, both can operate on separate planes, to some degree. One doesn't have to supersede the other. People in the past have seen how technology can be a wonderful tool for solving problems, but also a pretty devastating tool for creating problems. Power plants vs. atomic bombs are the cliched examples. The need to understand how to use our powerful scientific tools for 'good' is going to become more and more of a big deal as time goes on, so that means we're going to need more and more people to think about what 'good' actually means. That means art and philosophy can still be important, even as our society becomes more and more technologically advanced. Though they may not help create the technological advancement, they can teach us to be aware of the consequences of our actions and protect us from using our technology against ourselves. Empathy, human feeling, and ethical ideals will also have to increase as our technology becomes more able to change our brains, genes, and earth.

http://www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/brave-new-world-at-75